WEBVTT
00:00:02.944 --> 00:00:04.767
Hey there, welcome to the PR Breakdown.
00:00:04.767 --> 00:00:06.572
I'm your host, Molly McPherson.
00:00:06.572 --> 00:00:12.311
This week, the messaging behind two movements dominating our newsfeed.
00:00:12.311 --> 00:00:19.635
In this episode we're diving into something absolutely fascinating and, honestly, a little scary.
00:00:19.635 --> 00:00:30.472
We're witnessing two massive PR campaigns happening simultaneously in the US right now, and they're both straight out of a playbook written over 100 years ago.
00:00:30.472 --> 00:00:41.036
On one side, you have Trump's highly centralized, militarized immigration enforcement messaging, complete with noir-style footage and World War II-esque imagery.
00:00:41.036 --> 00:00:49.366
On the other, a decentralized, grassroots movement called no Kings that had over 2,000 protests happening last weekend.
00:00:50.027 --> 00:00:52.774
But here's what got my Gen X brain spinning.
00:00:52.774 --> 00:01:02.747
When I first heard about no Kings, all I could think about was one of my favorite Saturday morning television programs, schoolhouse Rock.
00:01:02.747 --> 00:01:11.368
Do you remember the cartoon, the no Kings cartoon, when they were singing about the American Revolution?
00:01:11.368 --> 00:01:17.332
This is where I wish I could bust through copyright and play it instead of doing this to you.
00:01:17.332 --> 00:01:21.222
They wanted no more Mother England.
00:01:21.222 --> 00:01:24.670
They knew the time had come for them to take command.
00:01:24.670 --> 00:01:25.591
It's very.
00:01:25.591 --> 00:01:26.493
Do you remember this song?
00:01:26.493 --> 00:01:28.768
Can you sing it right off top of your head, like me?
00:01:28.768 --> 00:01:30.093
It's very clear.
00:01:30.093 --> 00:01:31.420
You're being unfair, king.
00:01:31.420 --> 00:01:34.266
No matter what you say, we won't obey Gonna.
00:01:34.266 --> 00:01:40.084
Hold a revolution now, king and we're gonna run it all away with no more kings.
00:01:40.084 --> 00:01:45.855
Okay, I will stop right there To all my fellow Gen Xers who watch this on Saturday morning.
00:01:45.855 --> 00:02:03.394
I'm sorry this is going to be in your head all day, like it has been in mine all week, but I'm telling you it's the same type of campaign, because it turns out that connection might be more strategically brilliant than anyone realizes.
00:02:03.515 --> 00:02:12.842
In this episode, let's explore why, using the framework of a one Edward Bernays, the so-called father of public relations, who literally wrote the book on propaganda.
00:02:12.842 --> 00:02:14.246
So let's break it down.
00:02:14.246 --> 00:02:23.925
Before we dive into the campaigns, I need to give you the lens that I'm going to use to analyze everything, and that lens comes from a man named Edward Bernays.
00:02:23.925 --> 00:02:34.665
Now, if you're like me and you took the APR test through PRSA, the Public Relations Society of America, I'm guessing you had this question on the test.
00:02:34.665 --> 00:02:36.871
It's all about Edward Bernays.
00:02:36.871 --> 00:02:41.126
So I have the playbook in front of me, crystallizing Public Opinion.
00:02:41.126 --> 00:02:44.191
I refer to it quite often in my work.
00:02:44.191 --> 00:02:51.247
It's copyrighted in 1923, this episode over a hundred years later.
00:02:51.728 --> 00:02:57.444
But what he wrote could send chills down your spine if you cared about PR in this way.
00:02:57.444 --> 00:03:23.360
He said, and I quote those who manipulate public opinion constitute an invisible government, which is the true from the government that manipulates public opinion.
00:03:23.360 --> 00:03:28.030
Now here's what's important to understand Public relations is human behavior.
00:03:28.030 --> 00:03:32.385
It's how we think, how we react, how we message things for public consumption.
00:03:32.385 --> 00:03:38.306
And that public could be anyone your employees, your customers, your voters, your family, your community.
00:03:38.306 --> 00:03:42.663
We all work in messaging, whether we realize it or not.
00:03:42.663 --> 00:03:45.932
Every single day, we're crafting messages for different audiences.
00:03:45.932 --> 00:03:57.050
The difference is most of us aren't trying to manipulate public opinion on a massive scale, but some people are, and they're using Bernays' playbook to do it, whether they know it or not.
00:03:57.050 --> 00:04:02.972
Bernays talked about how public opinion is formed through what he called the group and herd mechanism.
00:04:02.972 --> 00:04:06.590
He understood that people don't make decisions in isolation.
00:04:06.590 --> 00:04:13.889
They make decisions based on what they think their group believes, what they think is normal, what they think is expected.
00:04:13.889 --> 00:04:15.872
Does that sound familiar?
00:04:15.872 --> 00:04:20.959
Because that's exactly what we're seeing play out right now in these two campaigns.
00:04:22.281 --> 00:04:28.112
Let's start with the Trump campaign, because this is where Brunet's invisible government concept really comes into focus.
00:04:28.112 --> 00:04:34.293
First, we need to understand something crucial A lot of what we're seeing is theater, pure theater.
00:04:34.293 --> 00:04:42.023
Trump is using his authority to make moves, knowing full well that many of these moves will be challenged in courts, but he doesn't care about the legal outcomes.
00:04:42.023 --> 00:04:46.531
He cares about the imagery, the messaging, the theater of it.
00:04:46.531 --> 00:04:48.355
All that plays into his ego.
00:04:48.355 --> 00:04:52.709
And here's the thing Trump has always been our television president.
00:04:52.709 --> 00:04:59.733
The same reason his show the Apprentice, was successful is the same reason he's able to wield power so effectively nowadays.
00:04:59.733 --> 00:05:06.156
He understands television, which means he understands social media with the video component.
00:05:06.156 --> 00:05:08.081
He understands spectacle.
00:05:08.081 --> 00:05:13.372
He understands how to create compelling imagery that gets people emotionally invested.
00:05:13.372 --> 00:05:17.387
So let's break down his current campaign using Bernays' framework.
00:05:18.009 --> 00:05:24.331
Target audience number one, his base, but also moderate Americans who want immigration policy changes.
00:05:24.331 --> 00:05:28.564
And here's the uncomfortable truth that's a lot of people.
00:05:28.564 --> 00:05:31.069
This isn't just Republicans we're talking about.
00:05:31.069 --> 00:05:37.093
There are moderates and even Democrats who genuinely want an immigration policy that's actually enforced.
00:05:37.093 --> 00:05:40.684
The message we're delivering on our promises.
00:05:40.684 --> 00:05:42.346
We're bringing order and strength.
00:05:42.346 --> 00:05:50.321
The emotional appeal patriotism, strength and this is key fear of invasion.
00:05:51.564 --> 00:05:53.648
Now here's where it gets really strategic.
00:05:53.648 --> 00:05:56.153
The imagery we're seeing is very specific.
00:05:56.153 --> 00:06:05.730
You're going to see Mexican flags in the footage, not because they're necessarily dominant in the actual protest, because that's the imagery that supports the invasion narrative.
00:06:05.730 --> 00:06:19.853
You're going to see smoke, tear gas, masks, everything shot in that noir style black and white dramatic, scary armed soldiers, handcuffs imagery that deliberately evokes World War II deportation scenes.
00:06:19.853 --> 00:06:27.045
They're not necessarily putting this out on newscasts, but they're putting it out in their content on their socials.
00:06:27.966 --> 00:06:28.968
Let me give you the numbers.
00:06:28.968 --> 00:06:31.774
This is where theater and reality diverge.
00:06:31.774 --> 00:06:36.632
Trump's administration claims 200,000 deportations since the inauguration.
00:06:36.632 --> 00:06:42.699
Sounds impressive, right, but only 10,000 of those were voluntary self-deportations.
00:06:42.699 --> 00:06:47.880
And there are still 1.4 million people with final deportation orders who remain in the country.
00:06:47.880 --> 00:06:52.312
The visuals suggest overwhelming success, but the numbers don't back it up.
00:06:52.312 --> 00:06:54.302
That's the campaign, folks.
00:06:54.302 --> 00:06:55.925
That's the theater.
00:06:55.925 --> 00:06:58.209
But here's the thing.
00:06:58.209 --> 00:06:59.372
Is it working?
00:06:59.372 --> 00:07:07.730
That's the question we have to ask, because if people believe the theater more than the reality, then the theater becomes the reality.
00:07:10.161 --> 00:07:14.572
Now let's look at the counter-narrative, the no Kings movement.
00:07:14.572 --> 00:07:35.711
With no more kings, no more, okay, no more singing Molly, I promise and I have to start with this Whoever came up with the no Kings as the slogan is a messaging genius, because it does exactly what good PR should do it connects to something people already know and feel emotionally connected to.
00:07:35.711 --> 00:07:43.872
I may be the only person who hears no Kings from Schoolhouse Rocks, and if you're still singing it in your head.
00:07:43.872 --> 00:07:48.870
I'm sorry, but I honestly don't think that's where it comes from.
00:07:48.870 --> 00:07:54.291
The movement started on Reddit, which is where a lot of these grassroots movements begin now.
00:07:54.291 --> 00:07:59.271
It was created by someone who feels millennial, elder, millennial.
00:07:59.271 --> 00:08:05.052
He describes himself as an engineer by day, with a degree in marketing and a fascination with virality.
00:08:05.052 --> 00:08:09.920
Notice that Marketing background fascination with social media, virality.
00:08:09.920 --> 00:08:13.331
This person understands how messages spread.
00:08:13.899 --> 00:08:14.985
The numbers are impressive.
00:08:14.985 --> 00:08:19.130
February 5th, their first protest had 72,000 participants.
00:08:19.130 --> 00:08:31.863
April 5th, they claimed 5.2 million participants, and now so, at the time of recording, it will be tomorrow's protest, on Saturday, june 14th.
00:08:31.863 --> 00:08:38.293
They have over 2,000 planned events nationwide 2,000.
00:08:38.293 --> 00:08:41.643
That's not a protest, that's a movement.
00:08:43.467 --> 00:08:52.916
But here's what makes this different from other recent movements it's not just one demographic, it's not just women with pink hats, it's not just one racial group.
00:08:52.916 --> 00:09:00.000
It's everyone coming together under one umbrella and, strategically, they're being very smart about the messaging.
00:09:00.000 --> 00:09:04.609
They're using constitutional language, rule of law, democracy.
00:09:04.609 --> 00:09:06.673
They're timing it with Flag Day.
00:09:06.673 --> 00:09:09.283
They are reclaiming the flag.
00:09:09.283 --> 00:09:21.231
They're making a big push for it to be peaceful protests, not riots, because here's what they understand Trump wants people to protest in Washington DC.
00:09:21.231 --> 00:09:22.721
He wants the footage.
00:09:22.721 --> 00:09:28.524
He wants to be able to say look at these protesters attacking the very military that's protecting you.
00:09:28.524 --> 00:09:34.527
But the no Kings movement is doing something brilliant they're telling people not to go to DC.
00:09:34.527 --> 00:09:35.947
Don't give them what he wants.
00:09:35.947 --> 00:09:39.009
Don't feed the beast.
00:09:39.009 --> 00:10:07.113
In fact, last Friday on my got under his skin by attacking the ego.
00:10:07.113 --> 00:10:11.623
So it's exactly what they're doing again to Trump and, frankly, it's genius.
00:10:12.610 --> 00:10:14.073
So what are we really watching here?
00:10:14.073 --> 00:10:20.496
We're witnessing classic PR war tactics on both sides and they're using Edward Bernays' playbook again.
00:10:20.496 --> 00:10:28.798
Whether they realize it or not, trump is deploying what Bernays would call an quote invasion narrative Save the country from dangerous outsiders.
00:10:28.798 --> 00:10:46.870
The imagery is carefully curated Mexican flags waving from the California protests, palestinian flags, anyone who can be framed as others, or threatening no King's is using what Bernays would recognize as revolutionary symbolism.
00:10:46.870 --> 00:10:48.533
But they're being smart about it.
00:10:48.533 --> 00:10:59.423
Instead of resistance and saying this is the resistance which sounds reactive and angry, they're using no Kings, which sounds patriotic and foundational.
00:11:00.049 --> 00:11:03.015
One campaign is about order and strength and military power.
00:11:03.015 --> 00:11:07.323
The other is about freedom and democracy and constitutional values.
00:11:07.323 --> 00:11:12.518
But here's the crucial difference Trump's campaign is centralized.
00:11:12.518 --> 00:11:15.779
Everything flows through him and his administration.
00:11:15.779 --> 00:11:26.923
The no Kings movement is decentralized no single leader, no single point of failure, and historically, decentralized movements are much harder to stop.
00:11:26.923 --> 00:11:29.413
The framing couldn't be more different.
00:11:29.413 --> 00:11:34.471
Trump's campaign uses fear, invasion, chaos, the need for strength.
00:11:34.471 --> 00:11:41.203
No King's uses hope constitutional values, democracy, the promise of America.
00:11:41.203 --> 00:11:48.043
We've seen this before Hope elected Obama, fear elected Trump the first time.
00:11:48.451 --> 00:11:51.760
The question is, which emotion is stronger now?
00:11:51.760 --> 00:11:54.678
So what can you do with this information?
00:11:54.678 --> 00:11:57.720
How do you avoid getting swept up in the manipulation?
00:11:57.720 --> 00:12:00.157
First, recognize the techniques.
00:12:00.157 --> 00:12:11.058
When you see that dramatic footage of ICE raids, when you see social media posts from DHS, from ICE, ask yourself what am I not seeing?
00:12:11.058 --> 00:12:12.981
What's the full context?
00:12:12.981 --> 00:12:16.293
What emotion is this designed to trigger in me?
00:12:16.293 --> 00:12:23.596
When you see those revolutionary symbols and patriotic language, ask the same question what's the real goal here?
00:12:23.596 --> 00:12:26.082
What action am I being asked to take?
00:12:27.091 --> 00:12:29.235
Second, look at the numbers, not just the imagery.
00:12:29.235 --> 00:12:32.913
The most compelling footage doesn't always represent full reality.
00:12:32.913 --> 00:12:37.423
Third, understand that both sides are trying to get you emotionally invested.
00:12:37.423 --> 00:12:39.293
That's not necessarily bad.
00:12:39.293 --> 00:12:43.123
Emotions drive action and sometimes action is necessary.
00:12:43.123 --> 00:12:49.884
But make sure you're choosing your emotional investment consciously, not just reacting to whatever imagery is put in front of you.
00:12:49.884 --> 00:12:53.941
And finally, remember that in a democracy, your attention is power.
00:12:53.941 --> 00:12:57.716
Where you focus your attention, what you share, what you talk about.
00:12:57.716 --> 00:13:01.443
That's how you vote every single day, not just in elections.
00:13:01.443 --> 00:13:06.111
Both of these campaigns want your attention, both want your emotional energy.
00:13:06.111 --> 00:13:09.639
Both want you to feel like you have to choose a side.
00:13:09.639 --> 00:13:18.724
Maybe the real power is in understanding the game being played and choosing consciously how or if you want to participate.
00:13:18.724 --> 00:13:24.721
The success of these campaigns won't be measured by the loudest voices or the most dramatic footage.
00:13:24.721 --> 00:13:30.600
It will be measured by numbers how many people show up, how many stay home, how many take action.
00:13:30.600 --> 00:13:38.201
But regardless of which side you're on, or if you're not on either side, the real victory is in understanding how public opinion is being shaped.
00:13:38.909 --> 00:13:43.611
Once you see these PR strategies at work, you can't unsee them Now.
00:13:43.611 --> 00:13:48.155
This analysis, as I mentioned earlier, came from one of my live chats with my Substack community.
00:13:48.155 --> 00:13:54.600
If you enjoyed this format, I host these conversations regularly on both Substack and YouTube.
00:13:54.600 --> 00:14:01.235
I love to break down the PR strategies that I spot as current events unfold.
00:14:01.235 --> 00:14:12.765
You can find everything at prbreakdownmedia, that is a website that's based on Substack, or you can follow me on Substack at Molly McPherson.
00:14:12.765 --> 00:14:21.414
I've got exciting conversations coming up, including one with Dr Abby Medcalf and another with media training experts Warren Weeks and John Peranek.
00:14:21.414 --> 00:14:25.143
Both of them are my favorite media guys, both from Toronto.
00:14:25.143 --> 00:14:34.716
Plus, I'm launching a new tool it is a beta launch for my Substack members that applies these PR frameworks to real world messaging.
00:14:34.716 --> 00:14:43.543
If you want to be a part of that beta launch, then head on over to my Substack, become a member and then you will get all the information you need.
00:14:43.543 --> 00:14:46.193
Become a member and then you will get all the information you need.
00:14:46.193 --> 00:14:52.024
Thanks for joining me this week into our deep dive into the messaging wars.
00:14:57.830 --> 00:15:02.169
As I mentioned again, I'm recording this the day prior to the no Kings protests and birthday celebration for the army and President Trump.
00:15:02.169 --> 00:15:08.740
So remember this in a world full of spin, the truth is in understanding how the spin works.
00:15:08.740 --> 00:15:13.240
Until next time, let's all keep breaking it down.
00:15:13.240 --> 00:15:20.216
And no more kings, no more kings, no more kings.
00:15:20.216 --> 00:15:22.018
Okay, I'll stop.