Amanda Hirsch: The Notes App Apology Era Is Done

Amanda Hirsch posted a Polymarket ad about the Lindsay Clancy trial on the Friday that trial ended in a mistrial. By Sunday there was a Notes App apology on Instagram, three paragraphs, comments turned off. Most of the internet read the apology as the story. Molly's argument is that the apology is a red herring, and that anyone stopping there is going to miss what actually happened.

Because Amanda Hirsch does not have a Polymarket deal. Dear Media does. Her podcast sits on that network, Polymarket is a sponsor, and the two are already teaming up on a weekly show called What Are the Odds. So the ad was not a content creator's lapse in judgment. It was an employee doing her job inside a partnership she never signed. It is the same collision as Good Good Golf and Callaway the week before: a brand deal built to reach one audience, meeting public opinion, with the person on camera left holding it. Follow the money and the crisis is a prediction market trying to reach women through a media company.

Then the field guide. Law 3, it is never the thing, it is the response to the thing - the ad was the thing, the apology had one job and made it worse. Law 5, silence gets filled and never by your friends - turning the comments off only moved the conversation to Reddit. Law 7, the hard decision is invariably the right one, and the hard one was for Dear Media to say the word Polymarket out loud. Law 2, the crisis comes from inside the house. And Law 1, trust is the filter: podcast ads work because listeners trust the host, which is exactly what is spent when that expertise gets rented out.

Chapters:
0:16 — The Apology They Typed Instead of Filmed
0:43 — Why This Is Not About Amanda Hirsch
1:49 — The Lindsay Clancy Mistrial
2:25 — Why the Clancy Trial Was the Story of the Summer
3:10 — The Sponsored Reel That Started It
5:15 — The Replies, and the Retreat to Stories
6:45 — Reading the Notes App Apology in Full
10:25 — The Callaway Parallel
13:03 — What Are the Odds, and Who It Is Aimed At
21:03 — Follow the Money
22:16 — A Prediction Market Going After Women
24:39 — Law 3: It Is Never the Thing, It Is the Response
25:01 — Law 5: Silence Gets Filled
25:40 — Law 7: The Hard Decision Is the Right One
26:20 — Law 2: The Crisis Comes From Inside the House
27:02 — Law 1: Trust Is the Filter
27:27 — When Expertise Gets Rented Out
28:35 — The Apology Has Legal Fingerprints
29:13 — Who Was Left to Fall on the Sword
29:27 — Name the Crisis

Every week I break down the biggest PR crises in the news: the slips, the moves, the scandals, and the lessons behind the headlines. I'm Molly McPherson, crisis and reputation strategist, known to my audience as the PR Lady. This channel is home base for the podcast and my weekly Substack live chats. Subscribe and follow along.

👇 Stay Connected
📧 Weekly Substack Lives and Newsletter [https://mollymcpherson.substack.com/]

📣 Speaking Inquiries [https://www.apbspeakers.com/speaker/molly-mcpherson/]

🎙️ THE PR BREAKDOWN PODCAST [https://www.prbreakdownpodcast.com/]

🎙️ Apple Podcasts: [https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-pr-breakdown-with-molly-mcpherson/id1441897190]

🎙️ Spotify: [https://open.spotify.com/show/53jOIfJuu00dsZhQMgI1Id?si=a0152e4ce81b4725]

📱 MOLLY ON SOCIAL

TikTok: [https://www.tiktok.com/@mollybmcpherson]

Instagram: [https://www.instagram.com/molly.mcpherson/]

Substack: [https://substack.com/@mollymcpherson?utm_source=user-menu]

⚖️ DISCLAIMER

This video is for educational and commentary purposes only.
Some links may be affiliate links. Sponsorships are always disclosed in-video.
Videos are based on publicly available information unless otherwise stated.

Copyright © 2026 Molly McPherson. All rights reserved.